Why There's No Firewire on the new MacBooks.

And so my dreams of a new black MacBook with firewire have been dashed along with my hope of a return of the 12" laptop from Apple. I'll get on the latter issue at another post. There's much to be bothered about the lack of Firewire on the MacBook but thinking about Apple and how Apple has moved in the past, the removal of FW from the consumer line of the laptop is completely understandable, if annoying.

Think about what has happened in the consumer camera space in the past couple of years. We have DV cameras that record directly to hard disk. We have flip cameras that record directly to SD disk (I have an older one with horrible compression). And of course we have the regular still cameras that save internally and externally to a number of removable media. What do all of these cameras have in common? They can transfer files directly over USB/USB2 to any computer or can have their removable media inserted into a card reader that also connects over USB.

Therefore the need for FW in the consumer space going forward does not need Firewire. it only needs USB. I have no doubt that the monstrosity that is iMovie 7.1 will be made to recognize these kinds of cameras and media (assuming it does not currently do so). I have long ago created a DVD through iMovie with my flip camera and files imported from an SD card. it's not hard.

What Apple has done is said that it won't allow it's more pro customers get away with buying the low end Mac to do work with "higher end" cameras. At least that's my read. If you want to hook up a Camera that *requires* firewire to move data then you probably have the resources to ante up for a MacBook Pro and Apple will be glad to take your money. of course that annoys people like myself who wanted a smaller machine but still wanted the pro features a-la the long dead 12" PB which had everything except the expansion slot.

Now some people are moaning about the supposed loss of FW target disk mode. If you have a techie who complains about this, please reconsider paying for his or her service. All intel Macs can be accessed in target disk mode via USB. No it's not firewire, but it does the same thing. they can still diagnose the HD with utilities over USB.